Current:Home > FinanceSouth Carolina lawmakers finally debate electing judges, but big changes not expected -Wealth Harmony Labs
South Carolina lawmakers finally debate electing judges, but big changes not expected
View
Date:2025-04-17 02:35:28
COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — After months of just talking among themselves, lawmakers in South Carolina are finally debating making changes in how the General Assembly chooses judges.
Senators on Thursday took up a bill altering the procedure for picking who sits on the bench. But there are plenty of warnings that wholesale changes aren’t going to happen in the process by which the General Assembly votes on judges from the Supreme Court down to the Circuit Court.
Off the table appear to be changes like having judges get chosen in popular elections or having the governor appoint judges either with or without approval from lawmakers. Those big alterations would require a voter-approved constitutional amendment which starts with a two-thirds vote in the General Assembly.
Instead, the bill in the Senate mostly concentrates on smaller changes with the Judicial Merit Selection Commission, a group of legislators and lawyers who do extensive investigations into judicial candidates, a process that entails examining everything from their finances to their temperament to their knowledge of the law.
The bill would remove the cap of three nominees the commission sends to the General Assembly. Instead, all qualified candidates would go forward. It would also alter the makeup of the commission to allow appointments from the governor, the chief justice and a group of both prosecutors and defense attorneys.
The Senate spent less than an hour debating Thursday and mostly listened to a description of the bill. Republican Senate Majority Leader Shane Massey told senators to be ready for at least two full days of debate while the bill’s supporters promised to discuss a number of possible changes.
But big changes appear unlikely even after hours of hearings in House committees this year about how people in the state have lost faith in the system.
There were stories of judicial candidates being pressured to drop out of elections to prevent embarrassment. Others discussed how lawmakers would delay cases by abusing their legislative immunity to stay out of court if they have legislative work.
Some called for attorneys who are lawmakers to either be removed from the screening commission or from electing judges period because as lawyers they could end up arguing cases before judges who owe their job to a General Assembly election.
The legislators on the commission — all of whom are lawyers — struck back, saying some of the stories weren’t true and others were at best isolated cases blown out of proportion.
“This is not an indictment of the current system,” said Republican Sen. Greg Hembree as he explained the bill on Thursday. Hembree isn’t on the screening commission.
Most of the hearings were in the House, which came up with a list of things it would like to change, but hasn’t acted on that with a proposal yet.
And time is an enemy of any proposal. The General Assembly adjourns in early May and the whole reform idea would have to start at square one in 2025 if it doesn’t pass and get signed by the governor.
Since those hearings, supporters of the system have gotten some high-profile help from throughout the legal system.
At a Senate Judiciary Committee meeting on Tuesday, former Chief Justice Jean Toal said South Carolina elects remarkably well-qualified judges and the Legislature-elected system, shared only with Virginia, is vastly superior to public election of judges and all the problems with independence and competency that system causes.
“The system is good. but changing pieces of it — not throwing out the baby with the bathwater — is the way to go,” said Toal, who was the state’s first woman to serve as chief justice and was on the state Supreme Court for 27 years.
“The best regulation is self-regulation,” Toal told the senators several times.
Democratic Sen. Dick Harpootlian, a lawyer for five decades who is pushing for more reforms, gently pushed back on Toal.
“I’m afraid, as we’ve seen with legislators in the past, not all of them are susceptible to that self-regulation,” Harpootlian said.
veryGood! (1)
Related
- 'Vanderpump Rules' star DJ James Kennedy arrested on domestic violence charges
- Body of South Dakota native who’s been missing for 30 years identified in Colorado
- Hidden demon face lurking in 1789 painting uncovered by restorers
- NFL MVP surprise? Tyreek Hill could pull unique feat – but don't count on him outracing QBs
- Working Well: When holidays present rude customers, taking breaks and the high road preserve peace
- Jamie Lee Curtis Reunites With Lindsay Lohan to Tease the Ultimate Freaky Friday Sequel
- Actors back. Pandas gone. WeBankrupt.
- Man charged with killing a Michigan woman whose body was found in a pickup faces new charges
- Tree trimmer dead after getting caught in wood chipper at Florida town hall
- Taylor Swift nabs another album of the year Grammy nomination for 'Midnights,' 6 total nods
Ranking
- Where will Elmo go? HBO moves away from 'Sesame Street'
- DOC NYC documentary film festival returns, both in-person and streaming
- Wolverine football players wear 'Michigan vs. Everybody' shirts for flight to Penn State
- Taylor Swift reschedules Argentina show due to weather: 'Never going to endanger my fans'
- Whoopi Goldberg is delightfully vile as Miss Hannigan in ‘Annie’ stage return
- What is the average cost of a Thanksgiving meal? We break it down.
- Brazilian Influencer Luana Andrade Dead at 29 After Liposuction Surgery
- 4 wounded in shooting at Missouri shopping mall near Kansas City; 3 suspects in custody
Recommendation
Justice Department, Louisville reach deal after probe prompted by Breonna Taylor killing
Marilyn Mosby trial, jury reaches verdict: Ex-Baltimore prosecutor found guilty of perjury
4 wounded in shooting at Missouri shopping mall near Kansas City; 3 suspects in custody
A teenager taken from occupied Mariupol to Russia will return to Ukraine, officials say
How to watch new prequel series 'Dexter: Original Sin': Premiere date, cast, streaming
Former Indiana legislator agrees to plead guilty to fraud in casino corruption scheme
The Excerpt podcast: Politicians' personal lives matter to voters. Should they?
Man charged with killing a Michigan woman whose body was found in a pickup faces new charges